From AutoCAD (to ArchiCAD) to SketchUp… a race
Recent History Over the past few months I’ve made a couple of terrain models in ArchiCAD 14 and then exported them to SketchUp 8. At first this was done to figure out a way to collaborate with a fellow architect who is an avid SketchUp user. We both wanted to work in the program we knew best. After I modeled the first site it became evident that it was incredibly faster, more accurate, easier, and all around better to model the existing site in ArchiCAD rather than in SketchUp. Since then I’ve whipped up a few more sites in ArchiCAD to save time for the SketchUp users. Yes that’s right. I now model things in ArchiCAD for others to use in SketchUp because it is FASTER than my coworkers doing the work in SketchUp.
Challenge Accepted The first site we actually modeled head to head. I had been asked to model a site in ArchiCAD 14 and see how the export process worked. But I was busy with other work and hadn’t gotten to it. One day I saw my coworker starting to model the site in SketchUp 8 and thought “Crap. I can’t let him do that. That’s supposed to be my job!” I quickly dropped everything I was doing and prepared to build the site model in ArchiCAD. I opened up the .dwg survey we had, built a mesh and had it cleaned up in SketchUp before my coworker had even prepared the .dwg in SketchUp to a point where he was ready to model in 3D. My model looked great in both ArchiCAD and SketchUp. But my coworker decided it would be better to have the site modeled as stepped contours instead of a mesh surface. So I rebuilt the site out of slabs and was still done before a single 3D element was made in SketchUp.
 ArchiCAD 14 – Mesh site with lots of tricks. Thanks Eric Bobrow for that video on intersecting slabs and meshes. One of my favorite moves in ArchiCAD. |
 ArchiCAD 14 – lots & lots of slabs, each one has an ID corresponding to it’s elevation on the survey. The red lines are walls for the property line & setback on a wireframe layer |
 ArchiCAD 14 slabs exported to SketchUp 8 via save as .3ds file from the 3D window |
 ArchiCAD 15 to SketchUp 8 via .skp export… for some reason the side materials all went white |
Here’s the process and some more images:
Step 1 Drag and drop a .dwg from the surveyor into ArchiCAD. This is the easiest way to handle xref’s in ArchiCAD 14 and newer. It’s super slick, and deserves a blog post unto itself (like many other things mentioned in this experiment).
 The original site survey with plenty of contours not shown |
Step 2 Model the site in ArchiCAD (mesh or slabs), using the .dwg as an underlay. I typically put the .dwg on story -3 (below my lowest used story) and trace reference it in so that it doesn’t get in the way. I never use the actual lines from the survey because they rarely connect and everything can be simplified. Lines need to connect because site building involves a lot of magic wand usage (space+click). I also don’t use curved lines in my mesh contours or in my slabs. Curves are not necessary in meshes. When the mesh is set to smooth, you can’t tell the difference between a curved line with 40 nodes and 4 straight lines. Fewer nodes = fewer faces = less demanding on your computer. Same goes for sites built out of slabs. Your site model is already an abstraction based on an abstraction (the survey), so make your life simple and don’t be a slave to the surveyor’s goofy lines. Further more a simplified mesh or series of slabs is easier to modify later.
Step 3 Save the model as a .3ds file from the 3D window. Set drawing unit to 1.00 inches.
Step 4Â Open SketchUp 8, cry a little bit, go to FILE/IMPORT, select 3DS FILES (*.3ds), click on options, set the Scale in the 3DS Import Options in SketchUp so that Units are meters, pick your file and import.
 What you’ll see between your tears while importing the .3ds file into SketchUp |
The units part makes sense, right? Not to me. How did I figure this units weirdness out? I made a 10′ x 10′ x 10′ cube in ArchiCAD and continued to export it and import it with different settings until it measured correctly in SketchUp. Trial and Error… part of my problem solving arsenal. Okay, I realize most of my readers use the metric system and not imperial. Anyone know what the screwy export requirements are for meters in ArchiCAD to meters in SketchUp? Somehow I doubt it’s as nonsensical as inches to inches. Makes me think of this Youtube video about the pros and cons of metric/imperial (don’t worry it’s short).
 10′ x 10′ x 10′ cubes have lots of uses |
Conclusion of sorts So this was all done in ArhiCAD 14 on a Mac. With 15 (and earlier versions on a PC), one can just export directly to .skp via a free plug-in. I’ve played around a bit with that now. There are pros and cons to both methods. The export to .skp comes through much cleaner; no faces missing (which I sometimes noticed with the .3ds file). The export to .skp also retains layers. Which is awesome for exporting buildings. But I found with the stepped site model, the .3ds file was easier to break apart and clean up. This is probably more a reflection of my (happy) ignorance of SketchUp best practices than the actual advantages of exporting via .3ds or .skp. Anyways, I’m working on a new project with the coworker I mentioned at the beginning of this post. He’s once again using SketchUp 8. I’m now using ArchiCAD 15. Lots more to share. Let’s just say the theme of some future posts will be “Anything you can do, I can do better” and “Okay, I’ll steal that; what else you got?”
Your turn I know I left out a lot of little details, so please comment with your questions.
Your turn again Also, who else has experience with the connection between ArchiCAD and SketchUp? I’d love to hear your stories.
Want MORE? Check out this post on stealing materials from SketchUp and bringing them to ArchiCAD.
Did you Enjoy this Post? Follow Shoegnome on Facebook, Twitter, and Youtube for more!
Jared Banks
You can watch the video Eric Bobrow did that shows how to trim slabs to meshes and then cutting holes in meshes with those slabs here. FYI, it’s towards the end of the video. I used that technique to cut the roads in the mesh site.
eduardo
For the export from AC to SU try 39.37
Mimou Archi
so amazing thank you
Nkeze Chris
Good job,Mr. Jared. I’ve really learnt alot through ur posts. Pardon me for digressing from the topic at hand, but this is a problem causing me constant headache. How do i export my archicad model to 3ds max for rendering process? I use AC 12 and 3ds max 2009. Thanks. Keep the flag flying.
Jared Banks
Nkeze Chris,
Have you tried saving out as a .3ds file? I presume that should work fairly well. I don’t think you need the add-on to save as a .3ds file, just to import. Google archicad 12 3ds add-on and it’ll come right up. If the .3ds file doesn’t come through clean, I’m not sure what other formats 3ds max can open.
Pingback: Model a site mesh faster in ArchiCAD than in SketchUp? | GRAPHISOFT ArchiCAD in SA
Bee
Awesome! Now I just need to get my boss to upgrade to AC15.
Jared Banks
Bee, sounds good to me! 🙂
Fabio Cantu
So, I´m a Sketchup User, and also i love Archicad. But there is something that i HATE in AC is modeling a terrain (i´m not talking about importing TXT coordinates from survey method).
Actually I rather chew glass than do it in Archicad.
in the other hand, i can model it in sketchup in a minute with the sandbox tool.
I´m really eager to know how are doing it on AC.
Thank you.
Jared Banks
Fabio. Ouch! That is a rough statement! 🙂 When I first starting using the mesh tool to do sites back on ArchiCAD 9 I hated it. And I stopped doing them for a while. But once someone showed me the magic wand/contour trick, I was sold. I believe I originally learned the technique from the forum. This video explains how to do it. What’s great is that once you have the contours set, it’s very easy to alter them. Scott Berry talks about it in a LinkedIn discussion regarding this post. Let me know if that helps.
Enoch Sears
Jared, found you from LinkedIn, I’ve added you to my personal “BIM masters list”. 😉 Looking forward to learning and reading more…
Jared Banks
Thanks! Looking forward to seeing your website launch next week.
Diogo
Nice idea, never thought of using archicad as a initial tool for the site modeling, but I’m still a beginner on archicad :).
About your question on the units of the 3ds import and export, it is kind of simple, archicad when it is exporting it is asking you what is the unit your drawing is right now, but it always export the 3ds as meter unit. So if you do a 10 millimeter x 10 mm x 10 mm and export to 3ds to get it correct for other programs you also need to import as meter, at least this is how it works on my system.
Fabio Cantu
Jared, I´ve seen this tutorial once, it´s the like that one explained in the Graphisoft´s Interactive Tutorial Guide.
But what are you both saying is that:
– You receive the DWG lines contours from survey (which is already in 3d)
– Import in Archicad as a trace-reference
– select EVERY contour
– insert the contour height (????)
i really can´t understand the last part
isn´t that too much time-consuming?
i mean…
In sketchup or even Revit, i can just select every contours i have, click, and voilá
my mesh terrain is made. As simple as that.
I really like Archicad, and I DO want to understand how to do a terrain.
Thank you
Jared Banks
I’m not sure i can explain it better than that video. This technique assumes the survey is 2D and not 3D. If you have an importable 3D mesh then you’re done. Draw a basic mesh. Space+click over the lines of the survey (if they don’t need cleaning up) will add contours to the mesh. Then you click on each contour and give it a height. And you’re done. It’s quite simple. What you might be missing is that you are adding a height to each contour line, not to each node. When you select a contour you need to check ‘apply to all’ after you set the elevation. That will set the entire contour line to whatever height you choose.
I’m not sure what you mean by (in sketchup or revit) you select every contour, click, and have your mesh terrain made. How does the program know what elevation to use? There must be steps than that.
I thin it’s also worth mentioning that my article touches both on the how to and also the best practices. In all these programs there are fast, slow, clean, sloppy, etc. ways to do things. I’ll admit that my process could be sped up by cutting corners, but that can hinder usability.
Nikola Duzevic
Hey,
how would you suggest making a terrain model in Archicad (15) if you have a 2D drawing which has elevation points (not contours)?
Jared Banks
There might be a fancier solution, but I’d just quickly play connect the dots (if the site isn’t too huge) and then follow the same process as I usually do.